Ebert saw the film as a brutal satire of the American Dream. The "good guys" are the ones who refuse to grow up. The "villain" (Scott’s Derek) is a successful, sleek, Prius-driving entrepreneur who uses therapy-speak as a weapon ("The only thing that's going to be stretched is someone's face... across someone's fist"). Ebert noted, with a critic’s glee, that Derek’s comeuppance—getting punched in the face, losing his job, having his car vandalized—is presented as a moral victory. In Ebert’s reading, Step Brothers argues that success is overrated. Loyalty to your fellow chaos-gremlin is what matters. Roger Ebert died in 2013. In the years since, Step Brothers has undergone a seismic critical reappraisal. It is now frequently listed among the greatest comedies of the 21st century. Quotes from it have become linguistic shorthand ("Boats 'n Hoes," "Did we just become best friends?"). It is a cultural touchstone for a generation that came of age during the Great Recession—a generation that looked at the promise of adult life (careers, mortgages, 401ks) and decided, perhaps ironically, perhaps not, that building a bunk bed was a more worthwhile pursuit.
He called it "exhilarating," "sublimely ridiculous," and "a work of pure, uncut id." He placed it in the company of The Producers and Animal House . The review was not a guilty pleasure confession; it was a battle cry. To understand how a film about two men fighting over a drum set on a front lawn became, in Ebert’s eyes, a minor masterpiece, is to understand the very soul of his criticism. The surface-level reading of Step Brothers is easy. Brennan Huff (Ferrell) and Dale Doback (Reilly) are regressed man-children. They speak in high-pitched shrieks. They build makeshift weaponry from cleaning supplies. Their vocabulary is a barbaric yawp of insults: "You’re a fuckin’ liar, you’re a fuckin’ liar, you’re a fuckin’ liar!" roger ebert step brothers
Consider the scene that Ebert cited as the film’s centerpiece: the "cataline." In a moment of desperate, manic invention, Dale and Brennan decide to form a company to sell a fictional product: a bed that converts into a car (a "car-bed" or a "cataline"). They draw a crude picture. They present it to a room of stone-faced investors. It is the dumbest business pitch in cinema history. Ebert saw the film as a brutal satire of the American Dream
Roger Ebert gave it three and a half stars out of four. across someone's fist")
In the end, Roger Ebert’s review of Step Brothers is not really about the movie. It is a manifesto about the purpose of criticism. It is an argument that a fart joke, executed with the precision of a Swiss watch and the commitment of a Shakespearean tragedy, is just as worthy of analysis as a Bergman close-up.